ok! i have a theory!
(this post contains spoiler about Harry Potter 6.. so if u haven't read the book, maybe it's best for u to browse my other posts)i just finished reading Harry Potter 6 for the 2nd time...
n i managed to scrap up a few evidences to present some theories (about the "Snape's loyalty" stuffs):
- from the first book, Rowling always have a twisted endings, that always not like what's it look like from the beginning.. (exp: sirius-is-not-evil ending, moody-turned-out-to-be-crouch ending, etc).. But in this book, it's clear that Rowling tryin to make us think that Snape is evil from the beginning (2nd chapter)... So, i believe that, infact Snape's loyalty is always on Dumbledore (i believe it'll be proven on the final book)....
- I always trust Dumbledore's judgement (he never make a false judgement, right?).. So when Dumbledore said that he trusts Snape wit his own life, I believe it!!!!
- On the scene where Snape joined all the Death-Eaters , just before he kill Dumbledore... There's a quite long silence, which I believe there r some non-verbal words goin on between Dumbledore n Snape (Snape use Legilimency, right?)... I believe, Dumbledore has asked Snape to kill him.. n then Snape hesitated because he don't want to kill Dumbledore (Snape shows a great dislike in his face before killing him, right?)... then Dumbledore said "Severus, please..." ("please kill me," he mean)... Haha!!!
- I believe Dumbledore asked Snape to kill him, because maybe he thinks he couldn't make it after all.. (Dumbledore is already weak since fightin Voldemort the previous year).. So why don't take a li'l bit of advantages from it?? By killing Dumbledore Snape can earn Voldemort trust.. In the other side, I also have a different theory.. it's possible that Dumbledore don't want Snape to break 'the unbreakable vow' Snape has made wit Narcissa.. (Snape promised Narcissa that he'll carry out the deed that Voldemort has ordered Malfoy.. killing Dumbledore, it is)
- When Harry ran after Snape, Snape only block Harry's jinxes... When he said Harry belongs to Voldemort, why don't he take Harry to Voldemort instead?
- and then Snape said "....until you learn to keep ur mouth shut and ur mind closed, Potter!"... Snape is actually giving Harry advice... shut ur mouth=non-verbal jinxes; close ur mind=oclumency......
i know some of u wu'd disagree wit me..
But i just hope that Snape is not evil...
Because I hate the fact that Dumbledore made a wrong judgement about Snape..
I just like to think that Dumbledore is always right until the end of his life!!!!!!!!!!!
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home